UK medical regulator faces legal scrutiny after data leak to newspaper
Doctors referred to the GMC for alleged antisemitism and Islamophobia are seeking legal remedies after the regulator shared sensitive personal details with The Times.
By Meera Fletcher ·

Doctors in the United Kingdom who have been referred to the General Medical Council (GMC) for alleged antisemitism and Islamophobia are considering legal action. This move follows a recent disclosure in which the regulator shared sensitive data about these professionals with The Times newspaper.
The incident began when The Times submitted a Freedom of Information request to the GMC. The newspaper sought figures on doctors who had been complained about, investigated, or sanctioned for antisemitism and Islamophobia since October 2023. In its response, the GMC included the reference numbers of 223 doctors. These numbers allow individuals to be identified through the regulator's public database. Additionally, the response contained details regarding the doctors' ethnicities, a protected characteristic under UK law.
Claire Light, the GMC’s head of equality, diversity and inclusion, wrote to doctors' groups this week to address the error. She stated that internal data had been shared with The Times in error. The regulator has formally asked the newspaper to delete the confidential data and stop disseminating it. However, The Times has informed the GMC that it will retain the information even though it does not intend to publish it at this stage.
The GMC was forced to contact the affected doctors to apologize for the disclosure. Some of these professionals were unaware of the complaints against them because the evidence did not meet the threshold for a formal investigation. Many of the affected doctors have been involved in pro-Palestine advocacy since the start of the war in Gaza, leading to a rise in disciplinary procedures and complaints in the UK.
Tayab Ali, a partner at the law firm Bindmans, is representing dozens of affected doctors. He told Middle East Eye that efforts are underway to pursue criminal charges against the GMC. Ali described the incident as a serious data breach, noting that sending sensitive personal information to a media organization is one of the worst types of privacy invasions. He explained that under the Data Protection Act, knowingly or recklessly disclosing personal data without authority is a criminal offense.
Dr. Ghassan Abu Sitta, a British-Palestinian surgeon whose data was disclosed, called for the GMC's chief executive, Charlie Massey, to resign. Abu Sitta argued that the leak was not a simple human error but a result of the GMC's long-standing treatment of doctors of color. He also requested a public inquiry into what he described as institutional racism within the regulator. Abu Sitta was previously cleared of alleged antisemitism by the GMC's tribunal service, but the regulator is currently challenging that decision in the High Court.
Dr. Nadeem Crowe, an emergency doctor in London, expressed disgust at the leak. He was suspended from his job at the Royal Free Hospital in 2024 following an anonymous complaint about his social media posts. Crowe stated that he has no trust in the GMC and is taking legal advice regarding the disclosure. He noted that if a doctor made a similar error with patient data, they would likely face suspension or loss of license.
The data leak has raised fears of doxxing and harassment among affected doctors. One anonymous doctor told Middle East Eye that knowing a newspaper holds their information makes them feel vulnerable. This doctor had previously received threatening messages, including death and rape threats, related to their online advocacy. They have complained to the Information Commissioner’s Office and The Times.
Amira Nimerawi, CEO of Health Workers 4 Palestine, described the disclosure as a profound betrayal. She argued that a regulator unable to protect its own doctors' data cannot credibly claim to protect patients. She called for an independent inquiry and immediate deletion of the data by The Times. The British Medical Association also criticized the incident, stating that the newspaper's refusal to delete the data is unacceptable.
The GMC told Middle East Eye that it is very sorry for the incident and has reported it to the Information Commissioner’s Office. The regulator emphasized that it has requested the information be deleted. The Times did not respond to requests for comment by the time of publication. This leak occurs against a backdrop of increased scrutiny on pro-Palestine advocacy within the NHS, following a government-endorsed review that recommended mandatory antisemitism training for staff.






