Medicare costs: Half of beneficiaries face higher 2027 premiums
Open enrollment ends Dec. 7, and KFF data shows the average cost for those staying in their current prescription drug plan will jump from $34 to $51.
By Tomas Rahman ·

The window for choosing 2027 Medicare coverage closes on Dec. 7, and the financial stakes are rising for millions of Americans. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services oversees the system, which serves roughly 70 million people. While the federal agency describes the overall market as stable, new data reveals a sharp divide in costs depending on whether an enrollee changes plans or stays put.
According to an analysis by the health policy research nonprofit KFF, beneficiaries who do not switch their prescription drug plans will see a 50% increase in average monthly premiums. That figure rises from $34 to $51 per month. KFF estimates that approximately 10.4 million people will pay higher premiums in 2027. This count excludes additional costs from deductibles and coinsurance, which can also rise.
Juliette Cubanski, who directs the Program on Medicare Policy at KFF, noted that the national average premium increase for standalone drug plans is less than $1 a month. She said the discrepancy exists because the average is skewed by people who switch to lower-cost plans. "It is worth it to avoid any unpleasant surprises in the form of either higher premiums or higher cost sharing for covered services in 2027," Cubanski said.
The cost hike follows the 2025 introduction of federal caps on out-of-pocket drug expenses. The cap for 2027 is set at $2,400. Enrollees can choose to spread this limit across the year or pay it in a lump sum. However, the change coincides with the end of temporary federal subsidies that previously helped suppress premium prices. As a result, some beneficiaries who paid nothing for drug coverage in recent years will begin paying monthly premiums for Part D coverage in the new year.
David Lipschutz, a co-director at the Center for Medicare Advocacy, warned that the complexity of the system requires careful review. "People really need to do their research before they enroll in Medicare, because there are trade-offs," he said. He pointed out that while premiums may be low, cost-sharing requirements often increase. "There are going to be, often, increases in cost sharing and copays, increases in out-of-pocket caps, and reductions in the scope of some of the extra benefits that Medicare Advantage plans provide," Lipschutz said.
An estimated 4.3 million people must find new coverage because private insurers left the market. Those who want to remain in Medicare Advantage must select a new plan, or the government will automatically move them to traditional Medicare. For those moving to traditional Medicare, the plan does not include drug coverage. Enrollees must sign up for a new Part D plan separately to keep prescriptions covered.
Missing the Part D enrollment step can lead to a late-enrollment penalty on monthly premiums for life. If an enrollee chooses to leave a Medicare Advantage plan for traditional Medicare during their first year, they have a guaranteed right to buy a Medigap policy without a health screening. In most states, insurers can deny coverage or charge higher rates based on health conditions after that first year. Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, and New York are the exceptions to this rule.
For those whose Advantage plans were not renewed or consolidated, a window to switch to traditional Medicare and buy Medigap without a health screening remains open until March. SHIP counselors advise that enrollees list all current prescriptions and planned procedures, such as joint replacements or dental work, before making a decision. They also recommend verifying that preferred doctors and pharmacies are in-network.
State Health Insurance Assistance Programs offer free, unbiased plan counseling in person and by phone. The SHIP National Technical Assistance Center is reachable at 877-839-2675. Counselors can assist with applications for Medicare Savings Programs and Part D Extra Help, which offset premium and drug costs. Enrollees must also specify whether they want bills mailed or deducted from Social Security to avoid being dropped from coverage.






