Fiscal Gap: PBO Reports $331.6 Billion Rise in Federal Spending
The Parliamentary Budget Officer states that new spending commitments have consumed nearly all of the government's recent revenue gains.
By Tomas Rahman ·

The federal government claims it is shifting its spending priorities toward capital investments, but a new report from the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) suggests the deficit has grown rather than shrunk. The office of Annette Ryan, the PBO, released a series of reports on Tuesday that scrutinize the fiscal trajectory of the government led by Prime Minister Mark Carney.
Ryan stated that the overall fiscal situation appears more favorable than projections made in April. This improvement stems from better-than-expected economic results and higher global oil prices, which have increased tax revenues. Despite this additional financial room, the PBO projects that federal spending measures have increased by $331.6 billion across three spending plans tabled under Carney's administration.
Ryan noted that the government has already allocated 96 percent of this new fiscal headroom to fresh spending commitments. She argued that this spending has not led to a meaningful reduction in the deficit. According to the PBO, approximately 60 percent of this new spending is designated for day-to-day government operations rather than the capital projects that officials promised to prioritize.
In a media statement, Ryan summarized the situation by saying, “The government promised to spend less to invest more. This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more.” John Fragos, a spokesperson for Finance Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne, countered that about $90 billion of the roughly $150 billion in new measures announced in Budget 2026 is focused on capital expenditure.
The PBO report acknowledged that the November 5 budget did shift priorities toward capital spending. However, the document added that most new measures from Budget 2025 onward still go to daily operations. Fragos pointed to the government's fiscal anchors, specifically a declining deficit-to-GDP ratio and a pledge to balance the operating budget, as evidence of prudent management. He also noted that instances of borrowing beyond current means are intended to generate future growth.
Ryan warned that the margins for meeting these fiscal anchors are narrow. The PBO calculates that if the deficit is $2 billion higher than Ottawa expects in the next fiscal year, the government will miss its pledge to reduce the deficit as a share of the economy. The report also highlighted a dispute over how capital versus operating spending is defined. Ryan argued that using internationally accepted definitions would result in a failure to balance the operating budget over the forecast horizon.
The analysis indicates that total borrowing outlined in Budget 2026 is expected to reach $765 billion over five years. This figure is $476 billion more than the cumulative deficit of $289 billion. This total includes loans to Crown corporations and asset purchases, such as military equipment, which are paid for upfront but depreciate over time. Ryan noted that public debt costs are now the fastest-growing line item in the federal budget on a year-over-year basis.
During an appearance before the House of Commons finance committee, Ryan stated that these costs are expected to surpass the cost of federal health transfers to provinces in coming years. She explained that while investments in infrastructure and military equipment may yield returns, they also carry real costs that must be repaid. Ryan told members of parliament that these payments are due regardless of whether the specific projects succeed or fail.






