AdvertiseDonate
PortlandSeattleDallasJacksonvilleColumbusWashingtonBostonDetroit
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Fresh headlines, all day.
Digital News Live · 70 SW Century Drive, Bend, OR 97702

Scandal, relegation and the road back: how Europe's fallen giants and their fans endure

From Juventus to Rangers and Marseille, history shows punished clubs lose their stars but find unlikely heroes, while supporters cling to dark humor and loyalty.

By Meera Fletcher ·

Illustration for: Scandal, relegation and the road back: how Europe's fallen giants and their fans endure
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

For supporters of a once-great club, few things sting like watching your team sink into a crisis of its own making. Whether through cheating, financial mismanagement or simple ineptitude, some of Europe's most storied teams have been relegated as punishment, leaving fans to watch offices stripped bare while managers and players scramble for the first route off the sinking ship.

As Manchester City's fans await the results of the club's appeal and the level of punishment for 114 breaches of the Premier League's financial rules, they can draw some comfort, or renewed dread, from the way other giants have responded to the depths of despair.

The 2006 Calciopoli scandal in Italy began as a doping investigation into Juventus but instead uncovered evidence of attempted match-fixing by executives who manipulated referees and their bosses, a web that also implicated Fiorentina, AC Milan, Reggina and Lazio. Six days after Italy won the 2006 World Cup, Juventus were sent down to Serie B and stripped of their 2005 and 2006 league titles. Manager Fabio Capello had already left for Real Madrid, taking Emerson and Fabio Cannavaro with him, while Lilian Thuram and Gianluca Zambrotta joined Barcelona and Patrick Vieira headed to Inter. Zlatan Ibrahimovic, who refused to board the bus for a preseason game and hid in his room playing video games before joining Vieira at Inter, recalled the panic in his 2011 autobiography: "One after one the players got away .. every one of us who were left called our agents: 'Sell us, sell us.'"

Not everyone ran. Gianluigi Buffon, Alessandro del Piero, Pavel Nedved and David Trezeguet stayed and guided Juventus through Serie B. "We chose to stay together to honour a shirt, a club, a fanbase," Buffon wrote in La Stampa in 2017. "We lost everything to gain things which aren't measurable and can't be bartered: respect, affection." AC Milan escaped with a hefty points deduction and stayed in Serie A, though Andrea Pirlo admitted he would have left rather than drop down, writing: "There was no way I was going to pay for other people's sins, if that's what they turned out to be." The departed were not forgiven easily. "Any player who had left Juventus and came back to play would get booed. The fans felt betrayed," Lorenzo Bettoni, Football Italia editor, told ESPN, adding that they are still booed at the Allianz Stadium even now.

Fiorentina's collapse was crueler still, because the fans felt the club had not cheated. Declared bankrupt over unpaid debts and wages, the club was dissolved in the summer of 2002 and restarted in the fourth tier as a new entity. Angelo Di Livio, then 36 and fresh from Italy's World Cup elimination by South Korea on June 18, 2002, refused to flee. "Then I called [sporting director] Giovanni Galli and said, 'If you want, count on me. I'm staying,'" he told La Nazione. "I owed it to the Viola fans." Three months after that World Cup exit, he was starting a 1-1 draw at Sangiovannese. The rebuild was threadbare: manager Pietro Vierchowod recalled going to a shop with Galli to buy balls and shirts, with only five youth players at the first training sessions. "It was a horrible time for Fiorentina fans," supporter Lorenzo Lepore told ESPN. "The club hadn't cheated, instead it was the owners who let us down."

Rangers went through their own version in February 2012, placed into administration over a 9 million pound unpaid tax bill, then voted out of the Scottish Professional Football League and dropped to the fourth tier. Steven Naismith and Steven Whittaker were among those who left on free transfers. "I'll never forget those first few mornings going to training and seeing the boys disappear one by one," said Lee McCulloch, who stayed. "All they were guilty of was looking out for their families and their careers." On July 29, 2012, Rangers' first game back, a Ramsdens Cup tie at Brechin, was paused after 36 minutes while supporters shook the match ball down from a hedge, a world away from old rivals Celtic, who had just played Inter Milan in a preseason friendly.

Rangers won promotion that season and were back in the top flight by 2016-17, but the recovery has been rocky. "When they got back into the Premiership, there should have been a realization that they had to take things carefully," Andy Newport, sportswriter for the Daily Record, told ESPN, noting poor decision-making and repeated resets despite the 2021 league title, though fans now have genuine hope under American ownership and manager Derek McInnes. Marseille offer a similar warning. Relegated in 1994 for match-fixing just a year after winning the European Cup, they watched stars like Rudi Voller leave as Tony Cascarino arrived to lead the climb back. "I feel Marseille have still not recovered from their demotion, and it happened 32 years ago," Cascarino wrote in The Times, pointing out that a club which once won four straight league titles has claimed only one French championship since.

There is no single path back. In Portugal, Boavista supporters built a phoenix club, Panteras Negras FC, from the wreckage. Fiorentina, powered by Di Livio and Christian Rigano's 30 goals, reclaimed the ACF Fiorentina name and a Serie A place by 2004, two years after dissolution. Juventus embraced their role as chief antagonists, marking the 2012 Serie A title with T-shirts bearing the number 30, counting the two championships that had been taken away. "A title that's taken away and then not assigned or handed to another team remains an honor you've won," Pirlo said.

Through it all, supporters prize loyalty above everything, remembering those who stayed true and holding the departed to account. "In football, you can send a message to the outside with loyalty," Buffon told L'Equipe in 2018. "We play for fame, money, trophies and a lot of things, but we also play to feel a sense of belonging."

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Digital News Live in your inboxFresh headlines, all day. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Digital News Live in your inboxFresh headlines, all day. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.